How to choose

Midtown has two shops on West 35th Street, Best Bagel & Coffee at 225 and Liberty Bagels Midtown at 260. Best Bagel says it rolls its bagels by hand and boils them in a kettle. Ess-a-Bagel is another Midtown name, but its address is changing: one page of its site shows 770 3rd Avenue at 47th Street and its FAQ still gives 831 3rd Avenue. Check before you walk there.

Downtown, Apollo Bagels at 242 East 10th Street in the East Village is open every day from 7 am to 5 pm, and Tompkins Square Bagels on Avenue A is a short walk away. PopUp Bagels is in Tribeca. Murray's Bagels on Avenue of the Americas is in Greenwich Village. On the Upper West Side, H&H Bagels at 526 Columbus Avenue is reached by lines 1, B and C.

What it costs

Murray's shows 1.45 USD per bagel and 17.40 USD for a baker's dozen on its website in November 2026. Treat that as a guide, not a guarantee, as it has no update date.

Beating the queue

Tompkins Square Bagels advises weekday mornings or arriving before the weekend crowd for a shorter wait. The same idea works at any popular shop: go early.

Add a food walk

If you want more than a bagel, a guided food walk gives you several tastings. See New York food tours and what to eat in New York. For the neighbourhood around Katz's, see Katz's Delicatessen and the Lower East Side.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Going to Ess-a-Bagel without checking the address. It is moving.
  • Visiting a popular shop at midday on a Saturday. Go early.
  • Treating one shop as the best. Try two in the same area.
  • Using old prices. Check the shop's current menu.

FAQ

Where can I find bagels in Midtown? Best Bagel & Coffee at 225 W 35th St and Liberty Bagels Midtown at 260 W 35th St.

What are Apollo Bagels' hours? Every day from 7 am to 5 pm.

How much is a bagel at Murray's? 1.45 USD on the website in November 2026.

When is the best time to go? Weekday mornings are usually calmer.

Which shop is on the Upper West Side? H&H Bagels at 526 Columbus Avenue.

New York Authority editorial team, 14 November 2026. This page contains partner links: if you book, we earn a commission at no cost to you.