The guide-selected four

The Michelin Guide update of 20 March 2026 is the one outside selection used on this page. It does not claim a ranking, and a selection is not a promise that every pie will suit you. Four pizzerias on the table come from it. Roberta's is at 261 Moore St in Brooklyn. Speedy Romeo, at 376 Classon Ave, is also in Brooklyn and sits in a former auto shop. Una Pizza Napoletana, at 175 Orchard St in Manhattan, cooks in a wood-fired oven. Seppe Pizza Bar, at 3 Navy Pier Ct on Staten Island, has a view of the water, which makes it the one on this list that sends you out of Manhattan and Brooklyn.

Places with published addresses and hours

Joe's Pizza is at 7 Carmine Street, and its official site lists several other addresses in New York, so you can choose the closest one rather than travel to the first. John's of Bleecker St., at 278 Bleecker Street, is known for its historic coal oven. Its site gives opening at 11:30 am and closing at 11 pm on Friday and Saturday and at 10 pm on the other days (as of 8 November 2026). Joe's and John's share the 10014 postal code in lower Manhattan, so both can go on one walk.

Scarr's Pizza, at 35 Orchard St, publishes hours until 2 am on Friday and Saturday, which makes it the option on the list for a late slice. Una Pizza Napoletana is on the same street, 175 Orchard St, which gives you two stops on one block of the Lower East Side; for the area itself, read the Lower East Side.

Lucali has an active website with a reservation function, which suggests booking rather than turning up. It describes itself as made to preserve the owner's childhood candy store in Carroll Gardens, and availability should be checked for the date you want.

Which one for which plan

If you would rather taste several places with a guide, the box on this page shows a walking and tasting tour of Chinatown and Little Italy. It is food rather than pizza alone and it is the closest match we have, so use it as a way to eat across Lower Manhattan, not as a pizza tour. For a food-led neighborhood, see the East Village and Little Italy.

Brooklyn-style pizza explained

"Brooklyn-style pizza" has no single definition. It usually means a thinner crust and large, foldable slices, the shape most people picture when they say New York pizza. Because the label is loose, the best way to understand it is to eat it at a Brooklyn address.

Juliana's is a good place to start. It describes itself as a New York-style pizzeria, and it is at 19 Old Fulton Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201. The crust is thin and the pies are baked in the original hand-built coal oven. It sells whole pizzas only, with no slices, and it does not take reservations, so go with a group and expect a wait at peak hours. It is open every day except Thanksgiving and Christmas.

For more Brooklyn pizza, see Roberta's, Speedy Romeo and Lucali in the table above.

Una Pizza Napoletana, the world rankings and pizza tours

Una Pizza Napoletana (175 Orchard St) is the New York pizzeria that international rankings single out: the 50 Top Pizza World 2025 list places it at the top, shared with I Masanielli in Caserta, Italy, and the 50 Top Pizza USA 2025 list puts it first in the country, as it did in 2022 and 2024. Other New York names on the US list include Kesté, Ops, Pizza Secret and Ribalta, which won the New Entry of the Year award. Treat a list as one jury's opinion: it is a reason to go, not a promise that every pie will suit you.

Pizza tours are walking tastings, mostly in Greenwich Village: operator listings describe 2.5 to 3 hours with three to seven tastings, and some start near Bleecker Street. A tour gives you several slices and the history of the neighborhood in one outing; for a single famous pie, go straight to the pizzeria. The box on this page shows the closest guided option we have, a food tour of Chinatown and Little Italy.

Mistakes to avoid

  1. Treating a guide selection as a ranking: the Michelin Guide update names pizzerias it chose, and it does not put them in order.
  2. Going to Lucali without checking availability: it publishes an online reservation system, so check it for your date.
  3. Planning a Staten Island pizza by assuming the Manhattan hours: Seppe Pizza Bar's opening hours are not given here, so check them before the crossing; the Staten Island Ferry is a separate trip.
  4. Assuming Joe's has one address: its official site lists several, so pick the nearest.

FAQ

What is the best pizza in New York?

There is no objective answer. The Michelin Guide update of 20 March 2026 selects Roberta's, Seppe Pizza Bar, Speedy Romeo and Una Pizza Napoletana, and this page adds four more places with published addresses and hours.

Which pizzeria is open latest?

Scarr's Pizza lists hours until 2 am on Friday and Saturday (as of 8 November 2026).

What time does John's of Bleecker Street open?

At 11:30 am. It closes at 11 pm on Friday and Saturday and at 10 pm on other days (as of 8 November 2026).

Do I need a reservation?

Lucali has a website with reservations. For the other pizzerias, check each site for its booking rule before you go.

Which pizzerias are not in Manhattan?

Roberta's, Speedy Romeo and Lucali are in Brooklyn, and Seppe Pizza Bar is on Staten Island.

New York Authority editorial team, 15 November 2026.