| Hotel | Area | Known for (NYC Tourism) | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mandarin Oriental, New York | Columbus Circle | The Aviary NYC cocktail bar, Asiate wine collection of about 1,200 bottles | A Columbus Circle base next to Central Park |
| The Peninsula New York | 700 Fifth Avenue | Rooftop bar Salon de Ning on the 23rd floor, 54 suites, Mini Cooper chauffeur service | Fifth Avenue shopping and a classic hotel |
| Four Seasons Hotel New York | Billionaires' Row, Midtown | TY Warner Penthouse on the 52nd floor | Skyline and park views from a high floor |
| The St. Regis New York | Midtown | Landmarked 20-story Beaux Arts building, Astor Court afternoon tea | A historic setting |
| Park Hyatt New York | 153 West 57th Street | 25th-floor saltwater pool, about 350 works of art | Art, Carnegie Hall and Central Park |
| The Pierre | 2 East 61st Street | Opened in 1930, 189 rooms, Two E Bar and Lounge | Upper East Side and Central Park east side |
What the list means
The ten Forbes five-star hotels named in the 2018 release also include Baccarat Hotel, Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown near One World Trade Center, The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park, and Trump International Hotel & Tower. Ratings are renewed each year, so treat the list as a shortlist of the top end of New York, not a current guarantee.
The Peninsula and Park Hyatt
The Peninsula is at 700 Fifth Avenue with a rooftop lounge over Central Park and Fifth Avenue, an indoor pool and a spa. Its restaurant Clement serves American food and a Fifth Avenue weekend brunch. The Park Hyatt, at 153 West 57th Street, has 210 rooms and suites and keycards with artwork; its pool has underwater music curated by nearby Carnegie Hall. Read the Park Hyatt entry in our Hyatt guide.
Mandarin Oriental, Four Seasons and St. Regis
The Mandarin Oriental near Columbus Circle has a Presidential Suite with Central Park views. The Four Seasons on Billionaires' Row is the one with the 52nd-floor penthouse. The St. Regis is a landmarked Beaux Arts building and hosts afternoon tea in Astor Court. For the Plaza, Mark and Lowell compared with Park Lane see luxury hotels in New York.
Choosing between them
- Near Central Park: Mandarin Oriental or the Park Hyatt.
- Shopping on foot: The Peninsula or The St. Regis.
- A cocktail or a view from above: Peninsula's Salon de Ning, Mandarin Oriental's Aviary.
- Business in Lower Manhattan: Four Seasons Downtown.
- A different tone: boutique hotels in New York.
What to check in the Booking.com box
The box lists hotels in Midtown for your dates; search for the hotel by name. Rates move with the season and with events, so compare the total with taxes and fees, and the cancellation terms. See best time to visit New York.
Mistakes to avoid
- Treating a 2018 rating as current: check the Forbes list for this year.
- Mixing the Four Seasons Midtown with the Downtown hotel.
- Booking the Mandarin Oriental or Park Hyatt for Times Square: both are north of it, near Columbus Circle and Carnegie Hall.
- Comparing nightly rates without taxes and fees.
FAQ
Where is the Mandarin Oriental in New York?
In the Columbus Circle area.
Is the Peninsula on Fifth Avenue?
Yes, at 700 Fifth Avenue.
Which five-star hotel has a rooftop bar?
The Peninsula, with Salon de Ning on the 23rd floor.
Is there a Four Seasons downtown?
Yes, Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown, one block from One World Trade Center.
New York Authority editorial team, 14 November 2026.


