| Show | Format | Good to know (as of 13 November 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Jamie Allan's Amaze | Off-Broadway magic show | About 2 h 15 including an interval; GetYourGuide rating 4.8 out of 5 from 16 reviews; non-refundable |
| Monday Night Magic | Weekly Off-Broadway series | Described as New York's longest-running Off-Broadway magic show; the venue has changed, check the booking page |
| Chamber Magic | Salon show in the Lotte New York Palace, Midtown East | A parlor-style show for a small audience |
| Broadway Magic Hour | Family show in Times Square | Magic, comedy and mind-reading for all ages |
Which show to choose
For a first magic show, a full-length Off-Broadway production gives the most spectacle. Choose a small salon show for close-up magic, and a Times Square family show for children. Check the age guidance before booking: salon shows often suit teens and adults, and some venues serve alcohol.
Booking and timing
Book ahead for weekends. Several tickets are non-refundable, so confirm your dates before paying. For the show on GetYourGuide, see Jamie Allan's Amaze and check the date, price and cancellation rules on the offer page.
Art of Play in Brooklyn: a magic theater for 26 people
Art of Play presents close-up magic at 69 Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn. The theater seats 26 and is hidden behind the Curiosity Shop. Tickets can sell out several weeks ahead, and every show is for ages 21 and over. A run of shows is scheduled from 19 to 28 November 2026 at 7:15 pm and 9:30 pm. The venue asks you to arrive early and does not seat latecomers. Wine is included for that run, with the selection by Popina.
Planning the evening
Most shows are in Midtown and Times Square: see Times Square, Off-Broadway shows, Broadway tickets, comedy clubs and the last-minute TKTS booth. To sleep near the theaters, see where to stay near Times Square. For another illusion stop by day, read Museum of Illusions.
Mistakes to avoid
- Booking a non-refundable ticket before your dates are fixed.
- Arriving at curtain time: small venues start on time.
- Assuming every show is for children.
- Trusting a venue from an old listing: check the current address on the booking page.
FAQ
What is the best magic show in NYC?
It depends on the format: a full Off-Broadway show such as Jamie Allan's Amaze, or an intimate salon show.
How long is Jamie Allan's Amaze?
About 2 hours 15 minutes including an interval, per the GetYourGuide listing.
Are there magic shows for kids?
Yes, Broadway Magic Hour in Times Square is pitched at families.
Can I get a refund?
Not on all tickets: Amaze is listed as non-refundable.
More evenings out: New York at night.
New York Authority editorial team, 15 November 2026.



