Which SoHo hotel to choose

The six hotels differ more in what they offer than in location. All of them place themselves in SoHo or on its edge. The Dominick specifies Hudson Square–SoHo. For the neighborhood itself, including its cast-iron streets and shopping, see SoHo NYC.

  • You want a pool: The Dominick (outdoor pool at Terrace on 7) or ModernHaus SoHo (outdoor pool at the JIMMY rooftop, 18th floor). None of the other four hotels lists a pool.
  • You need more space: The Dominick lists one- and two-bedroom suites with separate living areas. This is the clearest option on this list for families or friends sharing.
  • You are one or two people on a tighter plan: Arlo SoHo publishes room sizes of about 150 square feet for a maximum of two guests. Budget for its urban fee as well (see below).
  • You want a small hotel: The Mercer has 73 rooms and suites, and Crosby Street Hotel has 86. ModernHaus SoHo is larger, with 114.
  • You arrive late or keep odd hours: Soho Grand Hotel lists a 24-hour concierge and 24-hour fitness. The Mercer lists 24-hour room service.
  • You will use the subway a lot: Crosby Street Hotel is the only one here that publishes walk times to stations (see below).

The six hotels

Soho Grand Hotel

The hotel is at 310 West Broadway, New York, NY 10013. It lists a fitness center open 24 hours a day and a concierge available 24 hours a day. On site are the Grand Bar & Salon and the Soho Diner, so you can eat and have a drink without leaving the building.

Arlo SoHo

The hotel is at 231 Hudson Street. Arlo publishes room sizes of about 150 square feet, for a maximum of two people, so it is not the pick for a family of three or more in one room. Guests have access to a partnership with Gotham Gym. Classes there must be booked 24 hours ahead.

On 9 November 2026, the hotel's FAQ listed a 2026 urban fee of $37 plus taxes per room per night. Add this to the room rate when you compare prices.

The Dominick

The hotel is at 246 Spring Street, New York, NY 10013, and describes its location as Hudson Square–SoHo. It has an outdoor pool at Terrace on 7, a Sisley Spa and a fitness room. Its one- and two-bedroom suites have separate living spaces, which matters if you are traveling with children or sharing with friends.

ModernHaus SoHo

The hotel is at 27 Grand Street, New York, NY 10013, with 114 rooms and suites. Its rooftop, JIMMY, is on the eighteenth floor and has an outdoor pool. The hotel restaurant, Selene, serves modern Greek cuisine.

Crosby Street Hotel

The hotel is at 79 Crosby Street, New York, NY 10012. It has 86 rooms and suites spread over eleven floors. Guests have a sculpture garden and a fitness room, and the hotel has the Crosby Bar and a restaurant.

The hotel publishes these walk times: two minutes to Spring Street Station and Prince Street Station, and five minutes to Broadway-Lafayette.

The Mercer

The hotel is at 147 Mercer Street, New York, NY 10012. It has 73 rooms and suites in a Romanesque Revival-style building. The minibar's snacks, water and soft drinks are complimentary. Room service runs 24 hours a day, and the restaurant is Sartiano's.

Getting around from SoHo

Of the six hotels, only Crosby Street Hotel publishes subway walk times. If quick subway access is a priority at another hotel, check the nearest station on a map before booking.

For fares and how the subway, buses and taxis work, see how to get around New York. If you are landing at JFK, compare your options in JFK to Manhattan.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing room rates without fees: Arlo SoHo listed an urban fee of $37 plus taxes per room per night for 2026 on 9 November 2026. Check each hotel's booking page for any fee of its own.
  • Booking Arlo for three: its published rooms are for a maximum of two people.
  • Assuming every hotel has a pool: only The Dominick and ModernHaus SoHo list one.
  • Expecting a walk-in gym class at Arlo: Gotham Gym classes need 24 hours' notice.
  • Skipping the availability check: all six hotels were presented on their current sites on 9 November 2026, but dates and room types still need confirming.

Other areas to compare

If SoHo does not fit your dates or budget, compare neighborhoods in where to stay in New York. For small design-led hotels in other parts of Manhattan, see boutique hotels in NYC. For higher-end stays, see the best luxury hotels in New York.

FAQ

Which SoHo hotel has a pool? The Dominick has an outdoor pool at Terrace on 7. ModernHaus SoHo has an outdoor pool at its JIMMY rooftop on the 18th floor.

Which hotel suits a family? The Dominick, which lists one- and two-bedroom suites with separate living spaces. Arlo SoHo's published rooms take a maximum of two people.

Which hotel is closest to the subway? Crosby Street Hotel publishes two-minute walks to Spring Street and Prince Street stations and five minutes to Broadway-Lafayette. The other hotels on this list do not publish walk times.

Are there extra nightly fees? Arlo SoHo listed a 2026 urban fee of $37 plus taxes per room per night on 9 November 2026. Check the booking terms for each of the other hotels.

Which hotels are the smallest? The Mercer has 73 rooms and suites, and Crosby Street Hotel has 86.

New York Authority editorial team, 9 November 2026.