Manhattan cocktail ingredients

The IBA specification calls for three liquids and a garnish:

  • Rye whiskey: 5 cl.
  • Red (sweet) vermouth: 2 cl.
  • Angostura bitters: 1 dash.
  • Garnish: a maraschino cherry.

That works out to about 2.5 parts whiskey to 1 part vermouth. Many bars pour a slightly different ratio, and some use bourbon instead of rye. Bourbon gives a sweeter, rounder drink. Rye gives a drier, spicier one.

How to make a Manhattan

  1. Fill a mixing glass with ice.
  2. Add the rye, the vermouth and the bitters.
  3. Stir until well chilled. Do not shake it, because a Manhattan is meant to stay clear and silky.
  4. Strain into a chilled cocktail glass (coupe or Nick & Nora).
  5. Garnish with a cherry.

Fresh vermouth matters. Once opened, keep the bottle in the fridge, because oxidised vermouth makes a flat drink.

Variations you will see on menus

  • Black Manhattan: the sweet vermouth is replaced by an amaro, a bittersweet herbal liqueur. It tastes darker and less sweet.
  • Perfect Manhattan: part sweet and part dry vermouth.
  • Dry Manhattan: dry vermouth only.
  • Bourbon Manhattan: the same drink with a sweeter base spirit.

If you want the classic, ask for a "Manhattan, rye, up". The bartender will then know you want it stirred and served without ice.

Black Manhattan: the Averna version and where to order it

The Black Manhattan replaces the sweet vermouth with an amaro, traditionally Averna. Averna's own recipe uses 50 ml of rye whiskey (Sagamore Rye) and 50 ml of Amaro Averna, stirred with ice in a mixing glass and garnished with a maraschino cherry. That equal-parts balance belongs to this recipe: other bars adjust the proportions and add bitters.

In New York, The Bar Downstairs & Kitchen lists a Black Manhattan on its menu made with rye, Averna, Angostura and orange bitters. It is at 485 5th Avenue at East 41st Street, on the Cellar level of the Andaz 5th Avenue, and serves dinner and drinks Tuesday to Saturday from 4 pm to 11 pm (November 2026). Ask the bartender for the rye and the amaro used, since the taste changes with the brand.

Manhattan vs Old Fashioned: what is the difference?

Both are whiskey cocktails in the International Bartenders Association list, and both use Angostura bitters, but they are built differently. The Manhattan is a stirred drink with vermouth; the Old Fashioned is a sugar-and-whiskey drink with no vermouth.

If you want a drink that tastes of whiskey with a little sugar, order an Old Fashioned. If you want something richer and herbal from the vermouth, order a Manhattan.

Where to order one in New York

Almost any serious cocktail bar in the city can make a Manhattan, so you do not need a special trip. Hours and prices change from bar to bar, so check each venue's own page before you go. Cocktail prices in Manhattan vary widely by bar and neighbourhood.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Asking for it shaken. It should be stirred.
  • Assuming "Manhattan" means one fixed recipe. Rye versus bourbon and the vermouth brand change the taste a lot.
  • Ordering a Black Manhattan expecting the classic. It is a different, more bitter drink.
  • Forgetting the age rule. The legal drinking age in New York is 21, and bars check ID, so carry your passport or a valid photo ID.
  • Skipping the tip. See tipping in New York for what bartenders expect.

FAQ

Is a Manhattan sweet? It is moderately sweet, from the vermouth. Rye keeps it drier than a bourbon version.

Is a Manhattan served on the rocks? Traditionally no. It is served "up", chilled and strained. You can ask for it on the rocks.

Rye or bourbon? The standard specification uses rye. Bourbon is a common substitute.

What is a Black Manhattan? It is a Manhattan with amaro in place of sweet vermouth.

New York Authority editorial team, 15 November 2026.