The oldest places at a glance

Fraunces Tavern: the oldest roof

The building at 54 Pearl Street dates to 1719, when it was built as an elegant residence, and became a tavern in 1762. It grew into a centre of Patriot activity, and on 4 December 1783 George Washington and his officers met there for a farewell. The museum on the upper floor tells that story and holds a reenactment of the farewell on 6 December 2026. If you only want one old room with real history behind it, this is the one.

McSorley's: sawdust and two kinds of ale

McSorley's calls itself New York City's oldest continuously operated saloon, with 1854 as its start. Its own page says women were admitted from 1970 after a case that went to the Supreme Court, and it lists famous visitors without citing sources, so treat the stories as the bar's own. In practice the draw is the room: a narrow bar, no reservations, cash only, and a queue on weekend evenings. Go on a weekday afternoon if you want a seat.

Pete's Tavern: the Gramercy corner

Pete's Tavern stands on the corner of East 18th Street and Irving Place. The year 1864 is the date city guides repeat; check the bar's own history page for its wording. It takes dinner reservations with a two-hour limit and welcomes walk-ins in the Bar Room and on the patio, so it is the easiest of the four to plan.

Keens Steakhouse: the pipe collection

Keens opened as Keens Chophouse in 1885 under Albert Keen and became a gathering place for actors, producers and writers from the nearby Herald Square theatre district. It is known for about 90,000 clay pipes hanging from its ceiling, a figure from a 2008 review, and it won a 2013 James Beard Foundation America's Classic Award. Of the four, it is the one to book for a real dinner.

Other names you will see

Lists of old New York bars also include the Landmark Tavern, which city guides date to 1868, and the Ear Inn, described as roughly 200 years old. Dates for these vary between guides, so confirm on the venue's own page before building a claim around them.

Which ones are worth it?

  • For history: Fraunces Tavern, because the building and the museum are both real.
  • For atmosphere: McSorley's, if you accept the cash-only rule and the queue.
  • For an easy evening: Pete's Tavern, with reservations.
  • For dinner: Keens, booked ahead.

A walk that links them

  1. Start at Fraunces Tavern in the morning, while the museum is open from noon.
  2. Go to the East Village for McSorley's in the afternoon.
  3. Walk up to Gramercy for Pete's Tavern at dusk.
  4. Finish at Keens for dinner, a short subway ride away.

For food rather than history, the Lower East Side and the East Village are the best neighbourhoods to eat from stall to stall; see the Lower East Side and the East Village.

A guided food tour

If you want the neighbourhood context with tastings instead of a pub-by-pub plan, a guided food tour of the Lower East Side covers old-world New York food in a few hours. The GetYourGuide activity in the box on this page is the Lower East Side food tour.

Frequently asked questions

What is the oldest bar in New York? It depends on the definition: Fraunces Tavern has been a tavern since 1762 in a 1719 building, while McSorley's calls itself the oldest continuously operated saloon, since 1854.

Does McSorley's take cards? No, it is cash only, with no reservations.

Is Fraunces Tavern a museum? The building houses a museum, open daily from 12:00 to 17:00, and a separate restaurant.

When did Keens open? In 1885, as Keens Chophouse.

Do I need a reservation? Pete's Tavern and Keens take reservations; McSorley's does not.

New York Authority editorial team, 12 November 2026.